By Reza Ghafoorian, Principal Attorney, G2Z Law Group, PLLC
Why is concierge medicine in the DC, Maryland and Virginia region legally complicated?
A concierge medicine or direct primary care (DPC) practice that serves patients across the DC, Maryland and Virginia region (the "DMV") must satisfy three different legal regimes that do not agree with one another. The central question in each jurisdiction is the same: is the practice's membership fee payment for medical services, or is it the sale of insurance? The answer differs by jurisdiction.
Virginia has a direct primary care statute. Under Va. Code § 54.1-2997, a qualifying direct primary care agreement is not health insurance or a health maintenance organization, provided that the practice does not require patients to pay monthly fees before the period they cover. Va. Code § 54.1-2998 adds a mandatory disclaimer, required disclosures and signature requirements.
Maryland has no DPC statute. Bills to exclude DPC agreements from the Insurance Article were introduced repeatedly, including SB 727 (2020), and none was enacted. The principal regulatory guidance remains the Maryland Insurance Administration’s (MIA) Report on “Retainer” or “Boutique” or “Concierge” Medical Practices and the Business of Insurance (MIA-2008-12-002, January 2009), which identifies when a membership practice begins to look like insurance. The report is more than 15 years old, predates the growth of direct primary care, and some commentators consider it outdated (see Philip Eskew, Direct Primary Care Business of Insurance and State Law Considerations). It has not been withdrawn, however, and it remains the MIA’s only published guidance on the subject.
The District of Columbia has neither a DPC statute nor published guidance from the Department of Insurance, Securities and Banking (DISB) on concierge or membership practices. A DC practice must therefore rely on general insurance-law principles and conservative contract design.
The result is that a single physician offering one membership program to patients in Fairfax, Bethesda and Georgetown faces a statutory safe harbor in one jurisdiction, regulatory guidance in another, and silence in the third.
Should a tri-state concierge practice use three membership agreements or one?
A practice has two choices. It can maintain three separate membership agreements, one for each jurisdiction, or it can use one master membership agreement drafted to comply with the laws of all three.
In our experience, one master agreement is usually the better choice. A single agreement is simpler to administer, simpler to load into a patient portal, and easier to keep current when the law changes. It also avoids a common error: a patient who moves from Arlington to Silver Spring, or who receives care in more than one jurisdiction, signing the wrong form.
A single agreement works only if it is built to the most protective requirement on each point, while still accounting for the areas, such as medical records and consumer protection rights, where the jurisdictions require different terms.
Getting this wrong has consequences in each jurisdiction. An agreement that omits Virginia's mandatory disclaimer and disclosures falls outside the statutory safe harbor, and one that ignores the Maryland Insurance Administration's indicators invites scrutiny as unlicensed insurance.
The trade-off is that a Virginia practice gives up some flexibility that Virginia law alone would allow. For most practices, that cost is small compared with the cost of maintaining and enforcing three different contracts.
What are the top 5 legal issues for a concierge medicine practice in DC, Maryland and Virginia?
1. Is the membership fee the unlicensed business of insurance?
This is the threshold issue. Insurance is, in general, a promise to provide a benefit or service on the occurrence of an uncertain event in exchange for a fee. A membership that promises unlimited care for a flat fee can fit that definition, and selling insurance without a license is prohibited in all three jurisdictions.
Virginia. The safe harbor in Va. Code § 54.1-2997 protects only agreements for "primary care services" paid by a periodic fee, and only if fees are not required in advance. Every agreement must contain the disclaimer and disclosures in § 54.1-2998. An arrangement outside the safe harbor may fall within Virginia's broad definition of a health maintenance organization in Va. Code § 38.2-4300.
Maryland. The MIA's 2009 report treats an annual fee for an annual physical plus unlimited office visits as the business of insurance. It identifies warning signs: unlimited visits, no limit on enrollment, a fee that does not reflect the fair market value of the services, physician financial risk for services by other providers, and no right to terminate with a prorated refund. The report states that "the devil is in the contract."
District of Columbia. With no statute or guidance, a DC practice should assume a regulator would look at the same factors Maryland identified.
What is at stake: a membership program treated as unlicensed insurance exposes the practice to regulatory enforcement and penalties under each jurisdiction's insurance laws.
2. Which services may be included in the fee, and who provides them?
Many concierge practices bundle laboratory panels, imaging, physical therapy evaluations, medications or IV therapy into the membership. Each item purchased from another provider raises separate questions.
Insurance risk. The more a practice pays for care furnished by others, especially care that depends on whether a member becomes sick, the more the membership resembles insurance.
Self-referral and kickbacks. Maryland's self-referral law, Md. Code, Health Occ. § 1-302, prohibits referrals to health care entities in which the practitioner has a beneficial interest or compensation arrangement, unless an exception applies. Paying outside vendors for services included in the membership can create exactly these compensation arrangements.
Prescription drugs. Charging patients for drugs can be treated as selling or dispensing. Virginia makes it unlawful for a practitioner to dispense controlled substances, a term that includes Schedule VI prescription drugs, unless licensed by the Board of Pharmacy to sell them (Va. Code § 54.1-3304.1). Maryland requires a physician to hold a Board of Physicians dispensing permit, subject to limited exceptions (Md. Code, Health Occ. § 12-102). DC defines "dispense" to include selling a drug (D.C. Code § 47-2885.02). Re-billing members for pharmacy-filled prescriptions may therefore trigger licensing requirements in all three jurisdictions.
3. How do Medicare, Medicaid and HSA rules apply?
Federal program rules apply even to a practice that does not bill insurance.
Medicare. A physician who participates in Medicare may charge a membership fee only for services Medicare does not cover. The HHS Office of Inspector General's March 31, 2004 alert warns that charging Medicare patients extra for covered services can lead to penalties and exclusion. A physician who opts out of Medicare must sign a written private contract with each Medicare beneficiary before providing services, as required by 42 C.F.R. § 405.415. Medicare compliance does not disappear when a practice moves to a direct-pay model.
Medicaid. Enrolled Medicaid providers face limits on charging Medicaid patients privately, and a non-enrolled physician's prescriptions and lab orders may not be paid by Medicaid.
HSAs. Beginning in 2026, the One Big Beautiful Bill Act permits HSA-eligible individuals to enroll in a "direct primary care service arrangement" only if fees do not exceed $150 per month for an individual or $300 for more than one individual. IRS Notice 2026-5 defines these arrangements narrowly. The IRS left both limits unchanged for 2027 in Rev. Proc. 2026-24. Many concierge membership fees exceed these limits, so members enrolled in them may lose the ability to contribute to an HSA.
4. Are the fee, payment, renewal and termination terms enforceable?
Membership agreements are consumer contracts, and their payment terms are often where regulators and patients find fault.
Prepayment. Virginia's safe harbor is lost if monthly fees are required before the period they cover. Required annual prepayment, and enrollment fees that function as prepaid membership fees, can put that safe harbor at risk.
Termination and refunds. The MIA treats the lack of a mid-term cancellation right with a prorated refund as an indicator of insurance, and restrictive cancellation terms also draw consumer protection scrutiny.
Consumer protection. The Maryland Consumer Protection Act and the DC Consumer Protection Procedures Act apply to unfair or deceptive terms and marketing. Automatic renewal, fee increases and "guaranteed" access promises are common sources of consumer complaints.
Online reviews. The federal Consumer Review Fairness Act, 15 U.S.C. § 45b, voids form-contract clauses that restrict honest reviews. Offering a form contract that contains such a clause is itself unlawful under the Act.
Limitation of liability. A clause capping a patient's recovery for malpractice is unlikely to be enforced and may draw licensing board attention.
5. Licensure, telehealth and practice registration across three jurisdictions
A physician must generally be licensed where the patient is physically located at the time of care, including during telehealth visits. A tri-state practice therefore needs active licenses (and, where prescribing controlled substances, DEA and state controlled-substance registrations) in each jurisdiction where members are seen.
The practice entity itself may need to register as a foreign entity to do business in the other jurisdictions. Each jurisdiction also sets its own rules for medical records access, copy fees, record retention, minors' consent and telehealth consent. A membership agreement that ignores these differences may misstate members' rights in one or more jurisdictions. The same licensure and supervision questions apply to nurses, physician assistants and other clinicians the practice uses.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between concierge medicine and direct primary care? Concierge medicine usually charges a membership or access fee for enhanced access and may still bill insurance or Medicare for covered services. Direct primary care usually charges a periodic fee for a defined set of primary care services and does not bill insurance. The legal analysis differs, and many practices are a hybrid of both.
Is concierge medicine legal in Maryland? Yes. Maryland does not prohibit membership medicine, but it has no direct primary care statute. The Maryland Insurance Administration's 2009 report explains when a membership practice may be treated as the business of insurance, and practices should structure their agreements to avoid those indicators.
Does Virginia have a direct primary care law? Yes. Va. Code §§ 54.1-2997 and 54.1-2998 provide that a qualifying direct primary care agreement is not insurance, if the agreement includes the required disclaimer and disclosures and the practice does not require fees to be paid before the period they cover.
Does the District of Columbia regulate concierge medicine? DC has no statute or published guidance specific to concierge medicine or direct primary care. DC practices remain subject to general insurance, licensing, consumer protection and health care laws.
Can one membership agreement be used for patients in DC, Maryland and Virginia? Yes, if it is drafted to meet the most protective requirement of each jurisdiction and includes jurisdiction-specific paragraphs where the laws differ.
Can a concierge practice charge Medicare patients a membership fee? It depends on the physician's Medicare status. A participating physician may charge only for services Medicare does not cover. A physician who has opted out of Medicare must sign a private contract with each Medicare beneficiary before providing services.
Can patients use an HSA to pay concierge membership fees? Only in limited cases. Beginning in 2026, a direct primary care arrangement is compatible with an HSA only if fees do not exceed $150 per month for an individual or $300 per month for more than one person, and the arrangement meets IRS requirements.
Do I need a license in each jurisdiction to see patients by telehealth? Generally, yes. The physician must be licensed in the jurisdiction where the patient is physically located during the visit.
Conclusion: Experienced Legal Guidance Is Essential
Concierge medicine and direct primary care give physicians more time with patients and freedom from insurance billing. In the DMV, they also require a membership agreement that satisfies Virginia's statute, Maryland's insurance guidance, DC's general law and federal Medicare, HSA and consumer protection rules at the same time. A template from another state, or an agreement written for one jurisdiction, rarely does.
G2Z Law Group advises physicians and practices on concierge medicine and direct primary care membership agreements, Medicare opt-out and private contracts, and multi-jurisdiction compliance. To ensure full compliance before you launch or expand a membership practice, consult an experienced healthcare attorney. Contact G2Z Law Group to schedule a consultation.
This article provides general information only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws and guidance change; consult counsel about your specific circumstances. Reza Ghafoorian's bar admissions are listed on his attorney bio. G2Z Law Group represents clients only in matters in jurisdictions where its attorneys are admitted or otherwise authorized to practice.