Credentialing is serious business. Hospitals must constantly enforce their policies, assess risk and review standard of care to stave off liability and ensure quality of care. When a hospital determines that conduct of a staff physician rises to a risky level, it refers that member to peer-review for further investigation and corrective actions. However, a peer-review process can be unfair in the following five situations:
1. Competition Bias: When members of the peer-review committee compete in the same field of practice with the physician under review.
2. Management Bias: When the view of the medical staff and the hospital management is different with respect to “medical necessity of care.”
3. Narrow Specialty Disadvantage: When the peer-review committee members do not possess the experience and knowledge to review their specialized peer.
4. Violation of Clinical Autonomy: When the hospital management considers certain routinely performed procedures as having legal or compliance risk, and when physicians deem it necessary and effective.
5. Best Practice Bias: When there are two established, routinely practiced but conflicting practice protocols (e.g., neurosurgeons v. orthopedic spine surgeons) and hospital management elect the conflicting protocol as a standard of review.
Hospitals employ an army of attorneys and experts to assist them in implementing peer-review processes against staff physicians. It is important that staff physicians also seek competent counsel to assist them in navigating through the inherently bias and sometimes confusing hospital peer-review processes.